| 2025 All-ASUN Teams |
| First Team All-ASUN |
| SP Evan Dempsey, FGCU |
| SP Richard Long, Jacksonville** |
| SP Jonathan Gonzalez, Stetson |
| RP Ty Van Dyke, Stetson |
| C Trevor Conley, Austin Peay |
| 1B Josh Steidl, Jacksonville |
| 2B Kyler Proctor, Austin Peay |
| 3B Ray Velazquez, Austin Peay |
| SS Lorenzo Meola, Stetson** |
| OF ^John Bay, Austin Peay** |
| OF ^Cameron Nickens, Austin Peay |
| OF Jaden Bastian, Jacksonville |
| DH ^Cole Johnson, Austin Peay |
|
| Second Team All-ASUN |
| SP Gavin Braunecker, Austin Peay |
| SP Lyndon Glidewell, Austin Peay |
| SP Landry Jurecka, Queens |
| RP Kaden Humphrey, North Florida |
| C Matthew Delgado, North Alabama |
| 1B Gus Freeman, Austin Peay** |
| 2B Juan De La Cruz, Stetson |
| 3B Isaiah Barkett, Stetson |
| SS Landon Akers, Bellarmine |
| OF Evan Dempsey, FGCU |
| OF Parks Bouck, Lipscomb |
| OF Jordan Taylor, Stetson |
| DH Chandler Howard, Jacksonville |
|
| Third Team All-ASUN |
| SP Collin Rothermel, Jacksonville |
| SP Cole O'Brien, Lipscomb |
| SP Clay Hendry, North Florida |
| RP Nick Anello, Jacksonville |
| C Santiago Ordonez, North Florida |
| 1B Petey Craska, North Alabama |
| 2B Jonah Shields, Jacksonville |
| 3B Bryce Cermenelli, Central Arkansas |
| SS Andres Matias, Austin Peay |
| OF Zeb Allen, Central Arkansas** |
| OF Harrison Povey, FGCU** |
| OF Nick Monile, North Florida |
| DH Jack Witmer, West Georgia |
| ^ denotes a unanimous selection to the All-ASUN First Team |
| * denotes the number of career All-ASUN selection |
|
| All-Freshman Team |
| ^Cole Johnson, Austin Peay |
| ^Luke Davenport, North Alabama |
| ^Foster Apple, Stetson |
| Landon Akers, Bellarmine |
| Nathan Negre, Central Arkansas |
| AJ Groeneveld, EKU |
| Jon Embury, FGCU |
| Cayden Hessemyer, FGCU |
| Brady Miller, Lipscomb |
| Petey Craska, North Alabama |
| Seth Alford, North Florida |
| Bryson Treichel, North Florida |
| Ryan Brown, Queens |
| ^ denotes a unanimous selection to the All-Freshman Team |
