A late addition to the ’99 schedule, Division I-AA Morehead State rolled into Carrollton featuring the nation’s top-scoring offense led by one of the top quarterbacks in the country in David Dinkins, who rushed for 216 yards and four touchdowns and threw for 191 yards in the game.
The Eagles didn’t disappoint in proving they could light up the scoreboard, dropping 21 points on the host squad in the opening half to take a 14-point lead into the locker room.
Regrouping at halftime, West Georgia changed the narrative in a hurry, shutting Morehead out in the third quarter while scoring on a pair of Nick Price touchdowns to pull even at 21-all heading into the fourth quarter.
After the Eagles scored in the opening two minutes of the period, West Georgia answered with a 32-yard touchdown pass from Jeremy Clements to Roscoe Pounds with 2:39 to play to tie the game back up.
Morehead State had two chances to put the game away in regulation.
Driving down to the West Georgia 12-yard line, MSU place-kicker Guy Huffman hit the upright on his first attempt. An official, however, whistled a penalty on the play, giving the Eagles new life.
On the next attempt, West Georgia’s Johnny Leverette got his paws on the ball for the blocked kick, sending the contest to OT.
It was the West Georgia defense rising to the occasion on the Eagles’ opening possession, forcing a turnover on downs. That led to four consecutive Harold Farmer carries, the last of which resulted in paydirt and the six-point West Georgia victory.
MSU won the majority of the statistical categories, posting a 28-13 differential on first downs, outgaining West Georgia by a 521-347 margin on total yards and having an advantage of 36:15 to 23:45 on time of possession. But the only numbers that mattered to West Georgia when all was said and done was the final tally on the Grisham Stadium scoreboard: 34-28.